Canada considered letting in one million permanent residents in a year before settling on 400,000, according to government documents seen by the Toronto Star.
This was proposed as one of three options for how many PRs should be let in, with the pros and cons of each option. The deputy minister was in charge of drafting this plan for consideration by the cabinet in 2020, according to the Toronto Star.
The three options were:
Growth via covering up the 2020 shortfall over the next three years, with 401,000 people in 2021 (instead of 341,000), 411,000 in 2022, and 421,000 in 2023;
Maintaining the plan, with 351,000 people in 2021 and 361,000 in 2022, while consulting with Canadians about a steeper growth trajectory in the future;
Exponential levels of growth to see the 2021 target intact and the 2022 target up to 500,000, and one million in 2023.
Cabinet’s ultimate decision – to let in 401,000 PRs in 2021, 411,000 in 2022, and 421,000 in 2023 – was geared towards bolstering economic recovery after COVID-19, but has since received extensive criticism in recent months, in the wake of inflation, housing strains, and healthcare pressures.
“This proposal puts forward options that reflect the Government’s ambition and priorities for immigration,” says the memorandum submitted by then-immigration minister Marco Mendicino.
“All options signal future growth and reflect the continuing importance of immigration, with broad ranges for flexibility amidst uncertainty.”
The 2020 plan had aimed for 341,000 PRs. However, with the pandemic’s closure of the Canadian border, the proposal asked for growth.
“The proposed immigration levels plan aims to protect and enhance Canada’s immigration advantage, leverage it to welcome a growing number of newcomers who will contribute to short-term recovery and long-term growth, and seize the opportunity to help shape and support a future vision for our country,” the plan said.
As per the government, a “forward-looking” plan was to support family reunification, boost francophone communities outside Quebec, and keep Canada competitive on a global stage while addressing regional labor market needs and allowing more international students and foreign workers to become permanent residents.
Many critics are taken aback by IRCC’s consideration of letting in one million immigrants.
“Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada was foolish to think that one million was a number that would maintain public support for immigration,” said University of Ottawa law and public health professor Amir Attaran.
“We’ve never been close to a million and IRCC wanted the cabinet to consider doing something clearly out of precedent. It wasn’t gradualism. It was extremism.”
The cabinet report, however, did make note of possible challenges to the system for processing capacity and infrastructure as the department and its partners, such as the Canada Border Services Agency, would need $4 billion to $6 billion to manage the significant increases in admissions.
It also acknowledged possible increases in pressure on housing, education, and health service infrastructure for provinces and municipalities.
For 2024-2026, the department decided to stabilize immigration levels at 500,000; Canada would thus let in 485,000 PRs in 2024, 500,000 in 2025, and 500,000 in 2026.
